Civil Rights Seminar in Charleston, WV May 8-9.

On Tuesday and Wednesday, May 8-9, I’ll be co-presenting a civil rights seminar in Charleston, West Virginia on behalf of the National Business Institute.

The seminar is called, The Ultimate Guide to Police Liability Claims.  It is ideally geared towards lawyers, but would be beneficial to anyone related to the business of policing.  The seminar will come with a manual containing probably thousands of hours worth of experience and research into federal civil rights issues, and other information related to the civil liability side of policing.  Attorneys for both sides of the spectrum will be presenting.

Topics include federal constitutional law related to search and seizure, excessive force, and other common issues, as well as information related to police disciplinary issues.

Excessive Force Lawsuit Filed Against Logan County Deputy

The Charleston Gazette-Mail today reported on a lawsuit we filed late last week against a Logan County police officer for the use of excessive force against Mark Messer.

Here is the article:

Lawsuit: Logan deputy’s excessive force led to 17-day coma, long-term injuries

image

Mark Messer was never convicted of any crime.  However, during his arrest, his life was changed forever due to having his skull crushed on the asphalt by a Logan County, West Virginia deputy.

When Johnson began to walk Messer to his police vehicle, Messer turned his head and asked Johnson, “Who do you work for, the State Police, or the county?” according to the lawsuit.

The deputy “aggressively” replied, according to Messer’s lawsuit, then tripped Messer and pushed him to the ground. “Witnesses observed Johnson purposefully slamming plaintiff into the ground, in an apparent action in response to plaintiff’s question,” the lawsuit states.

 

With his hands cuffed behind him, Messer fell face-first onto the ground, as witnesses heard his head and face “loudly crack” on the ground and saw him “immediately start bleeding profusely,” according to the lawsuit.

 

Here is a previous post on the plight of Mark Messer, from back when he was still in a coma:

In the news: our client is on life support after use of force during an arrest

Katrina Seabolt says she witnessed a Logan County Sheriff’s deputy throw her brother to the ground about three weeks ago….

Mark Messer, 54, has been on life support in a Charleston hospital ever since an incident on Mud River Road in Logan on Aug. 18.

“It’s under investigation right now,” Logan Chief Deputy Mike Mayes said on Friday. “Whenever it involves use of force, this office investigates it.”….

Messer’s family has hired Monroe County lawyer John Bryan. He said last week that no one from the sheriff’s department has reached out to the family since the incident.

“My goals are to find out what happened,” Bryan said. “I want any documentation from law enforcement about the incident.”

Mark Messer was forced to go through an extended period of rehabilitation.  He had to relearn how to walk; how to talk.  Still, he never received any communications from Logan County.  Not an apology.  Not a conclusion to their “investigation.”  Not compensation for his severe life-long medical injuries.  Fortunately, he has the option of going to the federal courts to seek justice.

Several of my Federal Lawsuits Against West Virginia State Police Troopers In the News

A couple of days ago, the Charleston Gazette-Mail did an expose’ story on a series of 4 lawsuits against a West Virginia State Trooper.  3 of those lawsuits were my cases. They are now settled.

Accusations, lawsuits mount against WV State Police trooper

Four men have sued the same West Virginia State Police trooper in federal court over the past 18 months, alleging he beat them and caused broken ribs, concussions and spinal damage.

Senior Trooper Ralph Justus has been on paid administrative leave for a year, as he is the subject of an active internal investigation, according to State Police. No allegations in the lawsuits line up with the March 2017 administrative change.

Two of the men who sued Justus, Aaron Akers and Antonio Tolliver, settled their lawsuits last December for a combined total of nearly $190,000. Justus allegedly beat the two men in the hallway of the State Police detachment in Welch, beyond the range of building security cameras. Their settlements note they are resolutions of disputed claims, and the defendants are not admitting liability.

Another alleged victim of a hallway beating from Justus, Michael Ferguson, signed a settlement agreement for $75,000 earlier this month. A judge still needs to formally dismiss the case.

A funny part of the story, at least in a sad-funny sort of way, is that the defendant trooper was named “Policeman of the Year” by a local American Legion post.  This was for 2017.  According to the article, he was on administrative leave for  9 months of 2017, presumably due to allegations of misconduct.  Low bar, I guess.

Frank Cooley, a member of the post, spearheaded efforts to find a state trooper to award. He said while he did not remember Justus by name, the post generally makes its picks by calling a branch’s commandeer, asking for recommendations and voting on the shortlist internally. Two lawsuits had been filed against Justus months before the post issued its award.

Frank, you had ONE JOB.

 

New excessive force lawsuit in the news

We recently filed a federal lawsuit against two West Virginia State Police officers for use of excessive force on a man they were interrogating.  Our client is Bruce Bird.  The defendant officers are Trooper Bass and Trooper Young out of Clay County, West Virginia.

The Charleston Gazette-Mail recently published a story on the case:

The lawsuit alleges Bird, 30, was subjected to excessive force by the troopers and that the troopers withheld medical treatment to Bird, whose spleen was ruptured as a result of the alleged beating. Bird is represented by Monroe County lawyer John Bryan.

Bird was arrested, his lawsuit states, without incident on Feb. 13, 2015, and charged with robbing two gas stations. He was taken the State Police detachment in Big Otter and led to an interrogation room by Young and Bass.

As Bird was escorted to the chair he was to sit in, Bass, who was behind him, allegedly told him, “you know what we want you to say  the first word that you say that we don’t like, I’m cracking you in the ear,” the complaint filed Feb. 9 in federal court in Charleston states.

Bird’s complaint states that he wanted to say, “I don’t [expletive] know nothing,” but as he began to say the expletive, Young and Bass allegedly began beating him.

“The defendants were punching [Bird] with their fists, kicking him, stomping him,” the complaint states. “The officers struck him mostly in the back of the head and the ribs.”

. . .

After more alleged kicking and hitting, Bird said, “alright, alright, I’ll do whatever you want me to do, just quit kicking me,” his lawsuit claims. “I think you done broke my ribs anyway,” he said, according to the complaint.

“No, I know when ribs break,” Young allegedly responded. Young then “delivered one final blow which seriously injured [Bird].”

. . .

The medical unit at the jail immediately sent Bird to Braxton Community Hospital. While there, he passed out on the floor and was taken by helicopter to Charleston Area Medical Center General Hospital.

At CAMC, doctors told Bird his spleen had ruptured and that he might not live another hour without emergency surgery, according to the lawsuit.

Bird told the nurses, his lawsuit alleges, that “if I die, I want you to write this down, it was state trooper Young and state trooper Bass who did this to me. I want this out there so it doesn’t happen to somebody else.”

– See more at: http://www.wvgazettemail.com/news-cops-and-courts/20170219/lawsuit-claims-troopers-beat-robbery-suspect#sthash.xe9yAAJN.dpuf

Gun Law CLE 2017

Along with several other lawyers, including Ian Masters, I am co-presenting a legal seminar on gun laws in West Virginia on April 25, 2017 in Charleston, West Virginia.

The topics include West Virginia laws related to the concealed carry of firearms, relevant state and federal statutes pertaining to firearms, liability concerns, and more.

Although the seminar is geared towards lawyers, the information is necessary for all people who value, and who want to protect, Second Amendment rights.

Here’s a photo of me hard-at-work preparing my lecture:

image

Here is a link to the agenda and signup information.

Bumgarner excessive force lawsuit in the news

Today the Charleston Gazette-Mail published an article about the retired West Virginia state trooper we represent in a federal police brutality lawsuit.

Retired trooper John E. Bumgarner filed a lawsuit against the town of Alderson last July in which he accuses three of its officers of excessive force. Monroe County lawyer John Bryan, who represents Bumgarner, told the Gazette-Mail that he’s been contacted by agents with the Federal Bureau of Investigation, in Charleston, and officials with the Department of Justice, in Washington.

“They have requested the video footage and documents, which we are providing,” Bryan said Wednesday.

– See more at: http://www.wvgazettemail.com/news-cops-and-courts/20161228/feds-look-into-retired-wv-troopers-beating-claims#sthash.fDa5lseT.dpuf

 

FYI – new WV Supreme Court case: you can get a DUI on private property, on an ATV

An attorney friend if mine in my county told me about this case he had.  Apparently it was in the news and I missed it.  But I think it bears repeating.  A client of his was injured driving an ATV on his family’s (private) property.  He was charged with DUI.  The local court system threw the criminal charge out.  But the gestappo-esque DMV proceeded to suspend his license and litigate the matter all the way to the WV Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court ruled that the WV DUI statute applies anywhere in the state, including on your own private property – even on an ATV.  God bless the nanny state.  I feel safer already.

Read the opinion here.

Read the Charleston Gazette-Mail article on the opinion here.

Excessive force lawsuits filed against West Virginia State Police troopers

As reported in the Charleston Gazette-Mail this morning, last week we filed two new excessive force lawsuits against West Virginia State Police troopers.  Both suits have the same primary defendant trooper.  An excerpt from the article:

Two men claim in separate lawsuits filed in federal court that they were beaten in a hallway with no surveillance cameras inside the Welch detachment of the West Virginia State Police.

Aaron Akers claims in a lawsuit filed Friday that State Police Trooper Ralph Justus broke Akers’ back during a beating inside the detachment. Akers is also suing Trooper B.D. Gillespie, who he claims was in a nearby room with Akers’ brother and could hear the beating but did nothing to stop it.

Antonio Tolliver filed a separate lawsuit Oct. 27 against Justus, as well as Troopers Christopher Kane and Jacob Mann and another trooper who has yet to be identified.

Tolliver claims he was brutally beaten by the troopers two years ago in the hallway, which is located outside the booking room.

Both Tolliver and Akers are represented by Monroe County lawyer John Bryan, who said Friday that he is encouraging any witnesses to the alleged incidents involving Akers and/or Tolliver, or any similar incidents, to contact him. Sgt. Michael Baylous, a spokesman for the State Police, did not return requests for comment Friday or Sunday.

– See more at: http://www.wvgazettemail.com/news-cops-and-courts/20161106/lawsuits-claim-state-police-beatings-in-welch#sthash.wLxxCKom.dpuf

In the news: our client is on life support after use of force during arrest

image

image

Today the charleston Gazette-Mail featured our client, Mark D. Messer, who has been on life support since August 18, following a use of force incident during his misdemeanor arrest by the Logan County Sheriff’s Department.

Katrina Seabolt says she witnessed a Logan County Sheriff’s deputy throw her brother to the ground about three weeks ago….

Mark Messer, 54, has been on life support in a Charleston hospital ever since an incident on Mud River Road in Logan on Aug. 18.

“It’s under investigation right now,” Logan Chief Deputy Mike Mayes said on Friday. “Whenever it involves use of force, this office investigates it.”….

Messer’s family has hired Monroe County lawyer John Bryan. He said last week that no one from the sheriff’s department has reached out to the family since the incident.

“My goals are to find out what happened,” Bryan said. “I want any documentation from law enforcement about the incident.”

– See more at: http://www.wvgazettemail.com/news-cops-and-courts/20160905/man-on-life-support-after-beating-from-logan-deputy-family-says#sthash.RsJhU9yB.dpuf